Barbados is the most easterly of the islands in the Caribbean island concatenation. It is located at latitude and longitude 13 10 N, 59 32 W. the state has a tropical maritime clime with temperatures runing from 24 to 32 grades Celsius. The full land country is 430 sq kilometer and an sole economic zone of 200nm. Barbados had an one-year per capita GDP ( PPP ) of US $ 14,353 in 1999 bit by bit increased to US $ 17,956 in 2007 ranking it as the 37th state in the universe based on GDP, a population growing rate of 0.5 % and a human development index of 0.864 in 1999 easy lifting to 0.903 in 2007 and once more 37th in the universe based on its human development index ( UNDP Human Development Report 2009 ) . Agribusiness was one time the pillar of the Barbadian economic system in the signifier of plantation sugar production where break one’s back labor was used on plantations until the abolishment of bondage in 1834. Despite its comparative little size, Barbados gained the repute of the oldest and most profitable sugar settlement in the West Indies ( Barnes 1998 ) . Economic reforms in the 1940s and 50s the state underwent economic reform taking up to its independency from Britain on November thirtieth 1966. The state underwent structural accommodation in 1990 and at that clip, services and fabrication had overtaken agribusiness as the chief GDP earner.

Historical background & A ; description

The diminution of sugar plantations and outgrowth of peasantry in Barbados

Due to colonialization of Barbados by Britain in 1627, more than 300 old ages ago ( Beckles, H. 1990 ) , the state ‘s agricultural industry had rapidly developed into commercial plantation agribusiness. The commercialisation of the agricultural sector can be viewed as one of the cardinal indexs of the sector ‘s development ; nevertheless, apart from the commercialisation of the sugar cane industry, the remainder of the Barbadian domestic agricultural sector remained much less developed. Contrary to classical theoretical accounts of development, where feudal systems of agribusiness develop into a commercial industry, there was a mere 13 old ages after the British settlers foremost landed on the west seashore of Barbados that sugar and export oriented plantation agribusiness was introduced and later dominated Barbadian agribusiness. Natural flora was about wholly cleared and Barbados ‘s comparatively level landscape was transformed into sugar plantations ( Drummond and Marsden 1995. By 1834 at the clip of the abolishment of bondage, sugar plantations occupied about all of the 37,760 hour angle of cultivable land in Barbados. Entire land country of Barbados is about 43,000 hour angles so more than 87 % of the island was occupied by sugar plantations. Merely when sugar production started to worsen in profitableness that peasant farming emerged when cultivable land was released by the plantations for sale to ex slaves. ( Marshall et al 1974 ; Momsen 1998 ) .

Barbados could no longer rely on the sugar industry for increasing sums of gross due to limitations to entree in some European markets and intense competition from other sweetenings like high fructose maize sirup, Beta vulgaris sugar and unreal sweetenings ( Griffith 2002 ) . The outgrowth of the little husbandman as a characteristic of the Barbadian Agricultural sector came about with the diminution of the sugar industry. As more plantations went out of concern and sold land to ex-slaves the little husbandmans on the island bit by bit grew in figure. Land easy became available for non-plantation agribusiness but merely in little packages runing from less than 0.2 hour angle to 1.6ha. These secret plans were located on the periphery of plantations or formed bunchs of little retentions which were sugar plantations now purchased and divided among several proprietors ( Marshall et. Al 1974 ) . Constantly this land was among the least fertile of cultivable land on the island ( Shephard 1945 ) . This factor in the development of former British settlements was highlighted by Trotman et Al. ( 2009 ) where he elaborates that throughout the British Caribbean, challenges experienced by the peasant husbandman included the usage of low birthrate land for domestic nutrient production. These lands were characterized by sandy, bouldery or shallow dirts, hilly countries with hapless route entree to available lands and these lands were constantly prone to drought conditions in the dry season and implosion therapy in the moisture season. Institutional and infrastructural challenges besides existed with undeveloped marketing systems for domestic nutrient, inadequate or absence of equal physical selling installations ; hapless and uneffective institutional support for husbandman instruction, funding and procurance of production stuffs. This tendency continued good into the late 1980s where the Barbados agricultural nose count of 1989 showed that plantations of a size greater than 10ha merely accounted for 2.1 % of the state ‘s cultivable land, medium sized farms of 4-10ha occupied 83.1 % of the land and little retentions of less than 4ha accounted for 14.8 % of cultivable land. Harmonizing to the nose count these little husbandmans ( about 17,000 husbandmans ) accounted for about 98.9 % of the husbandmans in the state yet they controlled merely a little per centum of cultivable land. Peasant farmer entree to land was clearly one of the major restraints to domestic nutrient production in Barbados.

Literature reappraisal

Marginalization of the Barbadian peasantry

The diminution in sugar plantation profitableness of class saw an addition in the figure of little and average farms, but the overall tendency was a alteration in land use off from agribusiness. In 1834, about 36,760 hour angle of cultivable land were cultivated, in 1950 it dropped to 27,000 hour angles and by 1989 it was merely 12,000 hour angle or 55.6 % of the entire agricultural land ( Government of Barbados Census 1991 ) .

The alteration in land usage is reflected in the alteration in development focal point from agribusiness to a touristry and fabrication based economic system. The economic system was decidedly traveling off from a sugar and rum to services and fabricating but within the agricultural sector, production from little husbandmans was on the addition even if merely for a short period before a gradual diminution. Harmonizing to Singh 2002, it was clear that non-sugar agribusiness started to surpass the one time dominant plantation agribusiness. World Bank Development indexs show the gradual diminution of the part of Barbados ‘s agribusiness to GDP from 21 % in 1960 to a mere 4 % in 2005, while the part of services industries to GDP grew from 59 % in 1960 to 78 % by 2005, with an mean part to GDP transcending 79 % 2001 to 2004 ( universe bank development indexs 2010 ) . This fact was echoed by Potter 1998 where he saw that a concentration of services and modern retailing with many new elect residential countries stretching along the southern and western coastal countries of the island has developed with agribusiness being pushed out towards the North and E of the island. What did the displacement in economic focal point mean for little husbandmans?

Economist Winston H. Griffith in his 2002 diary article, ‘A Tale of Four CARICOM Countries ‘ , indicated that the small-producer dominated agricultural sector of Barbados has benefited from the flourishing touristry sector due to tourers ‘ strong penchant for local nutrients ( Griffith 2002 ) . However I caution such optimism since production in the Barbadian domestic agricultural sector remains sulky harmonizing to the Barbados cardinal bank study for 2006 and the tourer industry ‘s over 500,000 mean one-year long stay visitants every bit good as locals have remained mostly dependent on imported nutrient. So much so that of all the Caribbean states, Barbados has one of the highest leaden nutrient import dependence ratios in the Caribbean part and by and large slowdowns behind other developing states in footings of per capita nutrient production. This nutrient import dependance implies exposure to external nutrient supply dazes and universe tendencies in nutrient production can significantly impact its nutrient security ( Barbados Central bank study 2006 ) . Harmonizing to Kendal and Petracco, a worsening public presentation in agricultural export is taking to cut down employment, a diminution in existent incomes and increasing poverty of rural communities in the Caribbean by and large ( Kendal et al 2009 ) .

Clearly this downward spiral in agribusiness is cause for concern but Kendal et. Al. proposes rethinking the current theoretical account. They propose the redefining of success in agribusiness non in footings of export agribusiness ‘s part to coevals of foreign exchange and economic growing but in its part to employment, a more just distribution of income, poorness decrease, enhanced nutrient security, production and environmental sustainability.

State intercession

Entree to Land

There was no uncertainty that the Barbadian little husbandmans had fewer land acquisition options than their opposite numbers in the larger West Indian districts like Trinidad, Guyana, Jamaica and Belize. Apart from the trouble with acquisition of land from the plantations, the little husbandman now had to postulate with competition for land from the tourer sector which sought after land for the building of resort hotels and golf classs and the lodging sector which due to high demand and limited supply, land monetary values increased steadily ( Henshall Momsen 2005 ) .

Small scale agribusiness in Barbados has been a receiver of several policy holes and hopeful experiments on the portion of authorities with the hope that these little husbandmans will develop into economically sustainable endeavors of increased agricultural end product and increased incomes. Many former settlements of England during the postcolonial epoch sought to switch the balance of land ownership or set down entree off from the flush minority to the disfranchised multitudes. In Barbados the same policy was taken by authorities but in a much subdued mode and took the signifier of transition of authorities owned sugar plantations into little farmer secret plans. This enterprise was conducted as 2 separate undertakings, one in 1982 on a 427 acre plantation in Spring Hall St. Lucy and the other under the Land for the Landless programme in 2001 with 6 undertaking countries in the South, sou’-east and E of the state ( Pine Basin, River Plantation, Greenland, Bawdens, Sedgepond and Haggatts ) with land country numbering 615.4 estates. The plan besides included commissariats for private land proprietors to lease their land to husbandmans with no entree to land. The proviso of low-cost land to husbandmans besides came with a suite of services which included irrigation services, extension services and selling services. These plans were implemented by the authorities statutory bureau the Barbados Agricultural Development Corporation ( BADMC ) .The effectivity of these plans in bettering the predicament of husbandmans under this plan is nevertheless questionable ( Henshall Momsen 2005, Trotman et. Al. 2009 ) . The SHLLP was the first undertaking of this sort to be undertaken by the Government of Barbados ( GOB ) and had the undermentioned ends: “ to supply nutrient harvests in sufficient measure for local ingestion every bit good as regional and international exports ” . The aims of the undertaking included: “ to settle 22 renter husbandmans – who otherwise have small chance of bettering their criterion of populating – on feasible retentions with security of term of office ” ; “ to increase the productiveness of 402 estates of land through irrigation and better agronomic patterns aimed at “ off season ” production of harvests with higher value than sugar ” ( Catling, A. , Welch, M, Alleyne, S. , Gaskin, E. , Moe, R. 2008 ) . These ends and nonsubjective were similar in rule to those formulated for the land for the landless plan which was the GOB ‘s 2nd land rental undertaking implemented in 2001 besides by the BADMC. These ends were as follows: “ To increase the degree of production in agribusiness ” ; “ To supply increased employment chances in agribusiness ” and “ To increase the part of agribusiness to the Gross Domestic Product ” with general aims which included: “ To do available public and private agricultural lands to active and possible husbandmans ” ; “ To supply a bundle of proficient support services to take parting husbandmans in order for them to obtain maximal returns on their investing in agricultural undertakings ” and ; “ to supply and renovate farm substructure i.e. irrigation, farm edifices, A or other installations on public lands to ease the agricultural production procedure ” . The rental rates for land on the LFL plan is Bds $ 150 per acre per twelvemonth which harmonizing to BADMC records is lower thn lease of private agricultural lands which can run from Bds $ 200 to Bds $ 1000 per acre per twelvemonth depending on dialogues with the land proprietors. Land rental understandings are lawfully adhering contracts which give husbandmans entree to set down for 5 or 10 old ages depending on the nature of the agricultural endeavor, with farm animal raising and tree harvest husbandmans holding longer rental agreements than vegetable agriculture.

These land rental plans have experienced assorted consequences over the old ages with some husbandmans go oning production successfully and others discontinuing production or go oning with limited success. The BADMC continues to administer land to prospective husbandmans, provides free extension services and subsidised irrigation services, but critics of the plan have indicated that the irrigation services are still excessively expensive for husbandmans to get by ( Henshall Momsen 2005 ) with the high monetary values. These findings by Henshall Momsen were from husbandman interview responses and no information demoing irrigation cost as a per centum of overall husbandman disbursals was provided, nevertheless, the husbandmans who use subsidised irrigation supplied by the BADMC wage rates of Barbados $ 0.33/ M3 and $ 0.44 /m3. Other husbandmans outside of the BADMC irrigation undertaking pay the following rates based on volume use.

Basic needs – 0 to 8m3 at a rate of $ 2.48/m3

Normal Needs – 9 to 20m3 at a rate of $ 3.10/m3

Discretionary Use – 21 to 40m3 at a rate of $ 4.66/m3

Excessive Use – Over 40m3 at a rate of $ 7.78/m3

Commercial and Ship Bands – at the rates of $ 4.66 and $ 8.08/m3 severally.

Anecdotal information suggests most husbandmans fall in BWA ‘s Excessive Use class as indicated above. ( Beginning: Barbados Ministry of Agriculture Briefing October 28 2009: The Impact of Water Rates Increase with Reference to the Farming Community ) . It is rather clear that husbandmans who use authorities subsidized irrigation services pay well less for irrigation than those who do non. A mere 4.24-5.6 % of what non-subsidized husbandmans pay for irrigation. In two of the land rental farming countries, husbandmans entree H2O ways and irrigation pools built and/maintained by the BADMC but provide their ain pumps and irrigation lines to water their Fieldss. Datas on cost of irrigation utilizing this type of system is unavailable ( BADMC Economic Report 2008 ) .

critics of the land rental plan province that direction of the plan has non been effectual, more subsidies for husbandmans are needed, selling and promotional runs for farm green goods is required, the choice procedure of husbandmans for the plan should be revised and the lands should be evaluated for suitableness to agricultural production and extra services such as land cultivation and husbandman preparation should be included ( Henshall Momsen 2005 ; Catling et. Al. 2008 ; Trotman et. Al. 2009 ) . These are merely a few of the recommendations research workers who have studied the GOB land rental undertakings over the old ages, but with these recommendations and cognition of what needs to be done to better the plans, the jobs still persist. The implementing Agency ( BADMC ) itself operates at a loss and is subsidized by the GOB Ministry of Agriculture and farmer liability to the BADMC continues to lift yearly due to non-payment of land rents and for irrigation H2O use ( BADMC Economic Report 2009 ) .

If the decision of research workers and fiscal studies from the BADMC are the lone indicants of success or failure of the plan, so the plan has been a failure, nevertheless, husbandmans continue to be placed on the plan and agriculture activities still continue with some husbandmans go oning to better and spread out their production harmonizing to informations provided by the BADMC. This raises the inquiry as to whether the husbandmans on the plan truly do profit from the plan. The success of the plan from a undertaking direction point of position is tied to the ends and aims of the plan. In the instance of the SHLLP which was started more than 20 old ages ago, are these ends and aims still relevant in today ‘s economic and globally incorporate fortunes and is it just to mensurate its success or failure on these ends and aims? Rather than measure the success or failure of the LLPs entirely on these narrow aims, I propose that research workers should concentrate on the broader benefits to husbandmans ‘ supports.

The construct of Space and making by-passes for provincials ( Jan Douwe Van der Ploeg )


The chief aims of this research are to place and analyse the constraining production and market conditions which are impeding the success Barbadian provincial husbandman. Using this analysis I hope to supply feasible recommendations for the provincial husbandmans and policy shapers to:

Reduce dependence on imported agricultural inputs

Improve market entree for agricultural goods

Increase gross from agricultural trade goods

Create more employment chances in agribusiness.

Research Questions

What are the current restraints to peasant agriculture in Barbados?

Why do some LLP husbandmans win and others seem unable to win even with heavy subsidies?

What mechanisms or steps are presently used by successful provincial husbandmans to cut down production costs?

How can the authorities and husbandmans create more chances for peasant agriculture to win?

What are the preparation and instruction demands of these husbandmans in order to work these chances?

Research design


Analysis model


Durkheim E.1893. The division of labor in society

Trotman, A. , Gordon R.M. , Hutchingson, S. , Singh, R. , McRae-Smith, D.2009. Policy responses to GEC impacts on nutrient handiness and affordability in the Caribbean community. environmental scientific discipline policy 12 ( 2009 ) 529 – 541

Bert F. Hoselitz and Wilbert E. Moore ( 1963 ) Industrialization and Society

Beckles, H. 1990. A history of Barbados from American colony to nation-state. New York: Cambridge imperativeness.

Marshall, W.K. , Marshall, T. , Gibbs, B. 1974. The constitution of a peasantry in Barbados, 1840-1920. University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Barbados.

Singh, R. 2002. Deductions for liberalisation of Caribbean agribusiness: chances for the non-traditional subsector. In Caribbean endurance and the planetary challenge, erectile dysfunction. R. Ramsaran, 384-415, Kingston Jamaica: Ian Randle.

Government of Barbados. 1991. 1989 nose count of agribusiness. Bridgetown, Barbados: Ministry fo Agriculture Food and Fisheries.

World Bank, 2010. World Development Indicators Online. WorldBank, Washington, DC.

Griffith, W.H. 2002. A Tale of Four CARICOM Countries. Journal of economic issues vol. XXXVI No.1 March 2002

Kendal, P. and Petracco, M. 2009. The Current State and Future of Caribbean Agriculture. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, 33:780-797, 2009

Shephard C.Y. 1945. Peasant agribusiness in the leeward and windward islands. ICTA

Potter, R.B. 1998. From plantopolis to minimetropolis in the Eastern Caribbean: contemplations on urban sustainability. In resource sustainability and Caribbean development, explosive detection systems. D.F.M. McGregor. D. Barker, and S. Lloyd Evans, 51-68. Kingston Jamaica: The imperativeness, University of the West Indies.

Momsen, J 2005. Caribbean Peasantry Revisited: Barbadian Farmers over 4 decennaries. Southeastern geographer ; Nov 2005 ; 45,2 ; Academic Research Library pg 206.

Barnes, G. 1998. A Survey of Land Tenure Issues in Barbados: Concluding Report. ( Document prepared for Inter American Development Bank )

Central bank of Barbados. 2006. Central bank of Barbados 2006 one-year study. Central Bank of Barbados. Bridgetown Barbados

Catling, A. , Welch, M. , Alleyne, S. , Gaskin, G. Moe, R. 2008. Evaluation of the Spring hall Land rental Project. Unpublished research submitted as a research undertaking for the University of the West Indies PTMT 6011 Project Evaluation class.