While Rodriguez narrative Family Values high spots subjects of him sitting in his auto believing about how his household would respond to the intelligence his about to denote, how household values are used by the republican party and how they see immigrant households are n’t as developed and overhaul as Americans, and he besides covered the fact that households from different beginning of states have different positions when it comes to what truly household is and that they ‘re normally household oriented. Kingsolver narrative, “ rock soup ” exposes subjects of how the idea of most divorce household has changed the existent significance of traditional household and besides changed how society views toward individual parent has changed, how the economic system plays a immense function into redefining households by allowing individual female parents get a occupation and be able to back up her household, and she talked about how people should lose their negative positions about divorced household into failed matrimony. It is evident by contrasting these two texts that one can understand the true values of household no affair the state of affairs.
Rodrigues and Kingsolver both acknowledge the fact that household values differ from society to society. Rodrigues explains that a household value tends to change in different sorts of state around the universe. As a Catholic, a homosexual, a Mexican migrator, and an rational, for him the significance of household values tends to alter as his life go through different obstruction. He explains that the American belief of ‘family value ‘ is that the kids leave their place when they become mature plenty, live on their ain and discover about life on their ain instead than allowing their parent determine their future way by their past experience and encourages and state their kids “ go your ain adult male ” ( 322 ) . He besides mentioned that the belief of ‘family values ‘ is given through discoursing its usage among the politician party and it ‘s put to utilize to specify of migrators populating in America. “ Merely a society so guilty about its treachery of household would digest the piousnesss of politicians sing household values ” ( 322 ) .
On the 2nd narrative we can detect similar point of position from Kingsolver. The certainty that is in the caput of our modernize universe is that there no womb-to-tomb common “ traditional household ” . Kingsolver felt that most of us should n’t allow it refer us excessively much, “ Arguing whether untraditional households deserve commiseration or tolerance is a small like the medieval competition approximately left-handedness as a grade of the Satan ” ( Kingsolver 307 ) . Both narratives believe that the economic system plays a immense function into any household, and ever will play function into the strength and failing of a household. Kingsolver goes to into item refering households that suffered a batch through the great depression and explains that households who live in poorness had a major deficiency of money for lodging, She writes refering how the “ Family of Dolls ” theory was gave after the economic system increased to do certain adult females handed over their occupations to atomic household and soldiers while solo parent households descended and had hard clip economically. She note that households are ever being reshaped due to economic job and how solo female parents have more opportunity to be hired now when comparison to 1950 and are able to go a divorce and able to endeavor to success and supply any demands for their household and go “ happy ” .
Even though both narrative have similar point of positions on some portion of the narratives, but both narrative have different messages and discourse about some different job that everybody faces each twenty-four hours. Rodriguez highlighted that his job are relates many immigrant household and Tells shows his milieus are people from around the universe “ India lives following door to Greece, who lives following door to Russia. I wonder what the Chinese lady following door to my parents makes of the politicians ‘ phrase household values ” ( Rodriguez 322 ) . Typically when we talk about household values term, it ‘s a term used across the universe to sketch a set of ethical beliefs and traditional heritage impacting to every individual different state and their civilization. Family that comes to America from another state is more household oriented than Americans are “ Latino fond regard to household is seen by many Americans, I think, as the ground why Hispanics do n’t acquire in front. But if Asians in private annoy us for being so household oriented, they are besides stereotypically celebrated as the new “ whiz childs ” in school. Do n’t Asians travel to college, after all, to honour their parents? ” ( Rodriguez 326 ) . Family trust is holding a immense impact on households and that ‘s what is interrupting in America, Americans kids do n’t care about how their parents are making or they ‘re non every bit unfastened as in other civilizations and we keep secrets in order non to confront rejection by our households. “ Small 10-year-old misss know that there are grounds for acquiring off from the household. They learn to maintain their secrets — under lock and cardinal — addressed to Dear Diary ” ( Rodriguez 326 ) .
While both Rodriguez in “ Family Values ” and Kingsolver in “ Stone Soup ” usage subjects of household values and how everyone should lend to determine a perfect household by personal experience alternatively of allowing society alteration it. Both narrative besides portion their ain differences, Rodriguez talked about his sexual penchant and so he went on and explicate the positive positions and points about homosexual people contribute to society and to household. “ A cheery boy or girl is the lone 1 who is “ free ” ( married brothers and sisters are excessively busy ) . And, so, because we have admitted the inadmissible about ourselves ( that we are queer ) — we are aces at imaginativeness — we can even conceive of those who refuse to conceive of us. ” ( Rodriguez 324 ) . He so mentioned that the politicians have their ain definition when it comes to household values, more specifically Republicans. They tend to be careless when it comes to household values and do n’t even trouble oneself to speak about simple issue that most Americans households face each twenty-four hours, “ what do politicians, Republicans or Democrats, truly cognize of our household life? Or what are they willing to acknowledge? Even in that country where they could moderately be expected to hold something to state — sing the relationship of household life to our economic system — the politicians say nil. ” ( Rodriguez 322 ) . The other point that Rodriguez made was the fact that, how household values alterations due to the fact that different society and different civilizations from different state with their ain beliefs and thought about household values get to come to America and experience Americans household values. Most people who came to America from different state be given to be more household oriented than Americans. He besides said that other races have a wont of being stereotyped toward other races, “ Latino fond regard to household is seen by many Americans, I think, as the ground why Hispanics do n’t acquire in front. But if Asians in private annoy us for being so household oriented, they are besides stereotypically celebrated as the new “ whiz childs ” in school. Do n’t Asians travel to college, after all, to honour their parents? ” ( Rodriguez 326 ) .
Kingsolver ‘s narrative contains its ain originality because it covers about how society sees individual parents as a failing, how Americans are stereotyped and seems to be downgrading individual parents for a fact that bulk of Americans are individual parents, and she talked about how household need to portion and love one another. She gives inside informations on how she grew up with atomic household “ When I was a kid, I had two parents who loved me without cease ” ( 305 ) and now she comprehends the fact that she is a individual female parent but yet she and her girl are making mulct. She admits that divorce is merely a lazy manner to acquire out of matrimony and when she was a immature, she admired the idea of being portion of “ household doll ” so she realized that in her matrimony she did n’t happen that faery narrative which forced her into divorce “ . I did non wholly understand that another whole narrative begins at that place, and no fairy narrative prepared me for the combination of bad fortune and relentless hope that would disrupt my dream and take me to other agreements ” ( Kingsolver 306 ) .
In decision, both Rodriguez and Kingsolver have their different point of position that makes them who they are. While Rodriguez talked about being unfastened and allowing his households consume the fact that his homosexual, the politicians who ever seem to be concern about how the economic system making but failed to discourse on household values, and how immigrant household are more household oriented comparison to Americans household. Kingsolver acknowledges the fact that “ Family Dolls ” normally do n’t be due to the fact that every family faces some obstruction at some point in their life-time that reshape their matrimony and most of the would n’t experience bad when it comes to the thought of divorce. She besides reveal that acquiring devoice does non intend it ‘s a lazy and easy manner out of matrimony, everybody have their ain issues and we should n’t be judging others on how they should populate their life. At last, both narratives have one graphic message, and that is household value should n’t hold an lineation or a usher, It should be a learning experience and everybody should lend to that experience, “ Any household is a large empty pot, salvage for what gets thrown in. Each fret turns out different. Generosity, a resoluteness to turn bad fortune into good, and regard for assortment — these things will nurture a state of kids. ” ( Kingsolver 310 ) .
