With the generation in the USA and rapid spread all over Europe and Asia, fiscal crisis started in September 2008. Initially, impacting banking system as a consequence of mortgage convulsion for a really short period of clip it threatened the automotive industry. Harmonizing to the universe economic experts reports it is considered to be the greatest fiscal crises after the great depression of 1930`s. First symptoms were the high rate of unemployment and rising prices, hit of fiscal markets and prostration of fiscal and non-financial sector.

This planetary fiscal crisis associated with economic lag has had a profound impact in the non-financial sector and peculiarly in the automotive industry, which is decidedly an of import subscriber in the economic growing.

Since the public presentation of both states is extremely dependent in automotive industry, through this study we want to indicate out causes, challenges and the demand for province intercession during crisis.

After finalisation of econometric theoretical accounts and consequences, we will update this abstract.

Facts and general economic information

United States i?? USA

The world`s largest economic system with its nominal GDP estimated to 14,256,300 ( 1000000s of USD ) , is the taking state with i?? of nominal planetary GDP. Just before the crises U.S. economic system was known for its stable overall GDP growing rate, even though the entire trade shortage for 2008 reached 696 billion USD, ranking it as the largest importer partnering China, Japan and Germany.

As an of import tool of economic system building is recognition, public debt is around 53.5 % of GDP ( 2009 est. ) , while the largest holders are Japan and China. Estimates ( 2009 ) have shown that 1.2 % of GDP is composed by agribusiness sector, 21.9 % industry and 76.9 % by services. The US economic system is oriented on unfastened and extremely competitory markets. There are no barriers for foreign houses, despite the fact that bing houses are at or near the head in technological progresss. Leading industrial power, it is largely specialised in crude oil, steel, automotive, aerospace, and telecommunications industries.

Compared to the universe it occupies 4th topographic point for the labour force ( 154.2 million as of 2009 ) . More specifically, the fabrication employs 20.3 % of the US entire work force.


Largest economic system in Europe, Germany with its nominal GDP estimated to 3,346,702 ( 1000000s of USD ) is the world`s 2nd exporter with 1.120 trillion USD in 2009. Public debt is around 73.2 % of GDP ( 2009 est. ) , compared to its counterparty ( US ) the dependance in debts is higher. Estimates have shown that 20.4 % of GDP is composed by agribusiness, 29.7 % by industry while services sector leads with 67.8 % . In the way with most development states Germany is specialised in electronics, heavy machinery, Fe, steel, automotive, nutrient and drinks and fabric industries. Automotive industry is one of six largest sectors in Germany. For the labour force ( 43.5 million 2009 est. ) it occupies the fourteenth topographic point compared to the universe. The driver of globalised economic system has the highest qualified labor force and industry employs 29.7 % of its entire work force.

Graph. 1.1

The United States has shown stable growing inclination until 2008, while Germany graph shows more oscillations. In common belongings is the negative fluctuation in old ages 2008-2009, all this due to the fiscal planetary crisis. Purpose of this paper is to happen out whether the consequence of crisis in automotive industry had impact in GDP.

The Real Causes of the Automotive Industryi??Crisis

The root cause of the crisis in the automotive sector has been blame on the crediti??crunch that resulted from the mortgage meltdown. The economic experts and industry analysts believe that this unprecedented bead in gross revenues of cars is the consequence of a cyclical downswing compounded by inability of market participants ( traders and clients ) to seek for credits. The sharpest bead twelvemonth over twelvemonth of car gross revenues for any month on record, dating back to 1942 was reported besides by REUTERS, the first mark of an at hand automotive diminution on May 23 of 2008.

Remembering the oil dazes of the 1970s, above $ 135 a barrel oil monetary values were forcing the mean pump monetary values to the important degree ( $ 4 a gallon ) . Meanwhile rough oil monetary values, driven by concerns about tight stocks of refined merchandises in the short term and the great planetary demand over the long term have jumped 30 per centum. On the other side gasolene monetary values went up 57 cents/gallon compared to 2007.

Without uncertainty car manufacturers were stuck in an old and tired concern theoretical account, at which they are being unable to sell their merchandises. Uttered in economic footings, this means worsening in the demand for cars.

Under these fortunes, The Huffington Post ( December 12 2008 ) publicized the temporarily programs of General Motor ( GM ) . The interrupting intelligence was that in order to set the dramatically weaker car demand the company will shut its 20 makers for at least 6 hebdomads and do sweeping cuts to its vehicle production. Along that clip employees were temporarily laid off, having a part of their normal wage from the company. Among other they were free to use for province unemployment benefits, spokesman Chris Lee had declared.

Kevin Zeese ( November 2008 ) besides explained causes of the car industry crisis. The three major debatable issues in US are listed as follows: wellness attention system, the recognition crunch and low efficiency autos. Sing wellness attention as an out of control cost in USA ( compared to German automotive industry at which this cost is under control ) he does non waver to depict GM as vitamin E wellness insurance supplier that happens to do autos. The fact that the company spends yearly $ 5 billion on wellness attention increases the cost of each vehicle produced for $ 1,500. This world makes impossible the accomplishment of successful economic theoretical account for GM and furthermore it is something that can non be fixed by company itself. Ongoing, noticing for recognition crisis he treats the stock market as unregulated casino and blames the authorities for the inability of using basic ordinance to the fiscal markets and money supply.

Concentrated in these appraisals we qualify that the initial cause that pushed gross revenues down is alteration in fuel monetary values.

Changes in fuel monetary value

In world, economic systems of both states are challenged by fuel monetary value alterations. US Energy Information Administration information show that regular gasolene retail existent monetary value in 2000 was 1.89 $ per gallon, while in 2002 dropped to 1.64 $ per gallon. Since 2003 to 2008 the existent monetary value per gallon continued to lift until it reached the extremum in 2008 at 3.32 $ per gallon. In 2009 the monetary values started to drop but in 2010 and prognosiss for following old ages are that monetary values will go on to lift ( EIA 2010 ) . Approximately, the same form was besides followed for Diesel fuel retail monetary values.

As in the US, the form of fuel monetary values was similar in Germany. In 2000 monetary values were about 2.05DM1 per litter for leadless fuel and 1.77DM per litter for Diesel. The monetary values decreased in 2002 as in the USA happened to 1.07DM per litter for leadless fuel and 0.85DM per litter for Diesel ( The AA 2010 ) . The monetary values peaked in 2008, the same happened besides in Germany. In the studies of AA Public Affairs in October 2008 the monetary value per litter for leadless fuel was 1.35i?? and 1.29i?? per litter for Diesel.

Fuel monetary value alterations headed the demand for more efficient autos. Current vehicles were unaffordable taking into consideration fuel monetary value tendencies. As a consequence, the major car manufacturers were working to revamp their stock lists and seem to be progressively focused on the development of smaller, fuel-efficient vehicles.

Fluctuations started with dramatic beads in car gross revenues throughout 2008, possibly even earlier. Initially crisis was more perceptible in US instead than Germany. The deficiency of available recognition for purchasers and in the other manus the demand for money to cover the dramatic losingss in auto gross revenues of industry were major factors that the state of affairs was going more and more convoluted. Fiscal losingss came due to the increase of inducements or discounts that makers were forced to make in order to assist themselves on selling their merchandises.

Industry was foremost weakened by the 2003-2008 oil crises which in specific caused clients to turn away from sport public-service corporation vehicles ( SUV ) . In this respect, badly has been affected Porsche. Merely in the US market, gross revenues of German manufacturer slumped by 50 % compared to 2007. Furthermore, for four months the turnover was declined from 2.36 billion euro to merely 2 billion. This represents a bead of about 20 % compared to the same period of 2007. In the antonym, GM announced that it had sold about 36 % fewer autos in Germany compared to November 2007.

Talking in general, the overall US company gross revenues dropped dramatically in 2008. Fall is estimated to be 38.28 % , per centum significantly greater compared to Germany which has faced a bead to 18 % .


The chart clearly highlights the worsening of gross revenues compared to 2007 in US. As it has been mentioned earlier the peak point is September 2008.

In add-on by mensurating gross revenues as units of auto sold, informations provided by Bertel Schmitt for the twelvemonth 2009 presents a downswing in US close to 21.2 % . Whilst in Germany the opposite happens. An addition of 23.2 % is appeared due to the betterment of demand for little efficient autos.

The intent of handling gross revenues autumn is to warrant the undermentioned conflict on the production.

i??Demand is reduced! What happens with production? i??

With a virtually cocktail of negative ingredients, non surprisingly chief car manufacturers announced a psychiatrist of production. Initially it has been claimed for a temporarily decrease, but subsequently on for the fact that the state of affairs was non on the route to recovery many workss were closed by steering the industry to fell into a true recession.

Merely in December 2008, both together GM & A ; Chrysler were be aftering to shut 50 workss for at least one month. In this way many occupations were cut every bit good. For the ground that both economic systems are dependent on its public presentation, the failure of automotive industry would do the economic state of affairs even more baffling. Faced with the high rate of unemployment and the failure of major macroeconomic policies, province organic structures were willing to supply fiscal assistance.

Based on statistics of `Organisation Internationale des Constructeurs d’Automobiles` , decrease in US production had begun in 2007 while the other counterparty was executing better at that clip. Supported by the same information in 2008 the production was reduced for 19.4 % in US, severally 2.7 % in Germany. This weakening prompted the US to lose the 2nd place in the planetary automotive industry race. Datas of 2009 exhibit even a heavier dislocation with a shrinkage of 34.3 % in US and the oncoming of 13.8 % diminution for Germany.

Furthermore, a noticeable production decrease is perceptible from the planetary position. In 2008 the diminution was estimated to be 3.7 % , while in 2009 it became intolerable making the degree of 13.5 % .

Despite the fact that others were neglecting, in the other side were those who became more intense. Chiefly displacing and subsequently get the better ofing US, China has been making good. An addition of 48.3 % through 2009 was consequence due to the specialisation on bring forthing more efficient vehicles, costless labour force and stabile recognition capacity. In contrary, US and German automotive industry were more specialised on bring forthing SUV`s vehicles and the transmutation procedure should be backed with extra investings.

Consequently the cut of production has in bend affected dramatically employment. The US vehicle industry employs 880,000 workers or about 6.6 % of the fabrication work force. With the bankruptcy and restructuring of GM – Chrysler, plus the on-going recession, unemployment became the major job for both economic systems.


Statistically speech production, for every one of the 1000000s of Americans straight employed by the car industry, seven other Americans are indirectly employed by the glass industry, the steel industry, the rail industry, the plastic industry, and many other industries that all rely on the successful and continual creative activity of autos. This means that any financial crisis that impacts the car industry impacts non merely those employed by the car industry, but seven times as many other workers as good. In twelvemonth 2008-2009 the US automotive industry experienced the fiscal crisis. The American industry came to the decision that the onslaught of the fiscal oligarchy every bit good as an intense direction of the subsidies or revenue enhancement interruptions represented an applicable solution.

Without the governmental deliverance bundle the General Motors could non be helped, on the other side the car companies were confronting increased foreign competition due to public perceptual experience of foreign carsi?? superior quality and pricing. Furthermore, as a consequence of the oil crisis and the lifting popularity of the i??greeni?? motion, Americans preferred to purchase more environmentally friendly cars, which were more readily available abroad.

Even prior to the US fiscal crisis, Americans perceived US autos to be inferior to foreign autos. This perceptual experience was furthered by the media, which told Americans that American autos were less dependable, and of lower quality. This led to increased demand for foreign autos, which of necessity, led to a lessening in domestic auto gross revenues. Chrysler was forced politically to undergo a amalgamation with the Italian car manufacturer Fiat as a requirement to having any extra authorities assistance.

On the other side of our comparing: the German Car Exports had a robust rise of 44 % in the first half of the twelvemonth 2010 thanks to Strong Premium Market Recovery. The accelerated addition was aided by the low base degree recorded in the first half of 2009 and a sustained recovery in the planetary premium rider auto market spearheaded by highly strong growing in China.

The export tendency besides accelerated in June, with volumes lifting 26 % month-on-month during the month to 395,000 units. The difference between this fantastic German recovery and the US automotive industry lies in the German industrial political relations. With a clear package of puting and good pull offing the demand towards the foreign markets, the automotive industry proved to be the existent booster of the German quality and prestigiousness of the alone trade names such as Mercedes-Benz, BMW etc.

China was the existent growing engine of the planetary automotive industry in the first half of 2010 and this was particularly the instance for the German OEMs, with the premium trade names such as BMW, Audi, and Mercedes-Benz basking accelerated growing during the first half of the twelvemonth. Audi has announced that it delivered over 100,000 units in China for the first clip in the first half of 2010, with the company ‘s gross revenues lifting by 64 % y/y to 109,887 units.

Mercedes-Benz saw its gross revenues in China between January and May rise by 107 % y/y to 46,800 units, while BMW besides experienced a strong rise in volume. Mercedes-Benz and BMW have important rider auto fabrication articulation ventures ( JVs ) in the state through Beijing Automotive and Brilliance, severally, while Audi already has a important Chinese fabrication presence.

Whereas in the other industry: On December 19, 2008, i?? the bailout program was announced, which would give loans of $ 17.4 billion to U.S. car manufacturers GM and Chrysler, saying that under present economic conditions. Bush provided $ 13.4 billion now, with another $ 4 billion available in February 2009. The federal loan would hold prevented the General Motors from traveling into immediate bankruptcy. The bailout requires both companies to dramatically reconstitute their operations to show long-run viability. On 18 February 2009, the American automotive industry once more approached the US authorities, in respect to obtaining a 2nd bridging loan of $ 21.6 billion ( i??15.2 billion ) . $ 16.6 billion of this would travel to General Motors, while Chrysler would take $ 5 billion. General Motors agreed to cast 47,000 occupations, near five workss, and axe 12 auto theoretical accounts. Chrysler agreed to cut 3,000 occupations, cut one displacement from production, and axe for three auto theoretical accounts.

Empirical Methodology

In order to back up our analysis through empirical observation, we have used following econometric theoretical account which is being estimated for both USA and Germany individually:

Auto= ? _0+ ? _1? FSI? _t+ ? _2 X_t+ ? _t

Where Auto is representative for car industry advancement, FSI is fiscal emphasis index and X is the set of control variables.


We used fiscal emphasis indexs from IMF web site for each state to capture the impact of emphasis on car industry. We used value added by automotive industry in GDP as an index if car industry public presentation. The information was downloaded from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.bea.gov for all the indexs of USA. We used existent GDP every bit good as control variable. The beginning of GDP information was besides the same as of car value add-on.

Preliminary Consequences

Following are the preliminary consequences of our theoretical account for US. We found that fiscal crisis instantly affected the car sector. The relationship was found to be negative and important. The relationship of GDP was found to be positive with car sector public presentation which is in line with the economic theory.

Model 1: OLS, utilizing observations 1-45

Dependent variable: Value_added__Mo

Average dependant volt-ampere

These are merely preliminary consequences for USA. Our mark is to make the same appraisal with Germany. We intend to better our analysis with few more equations in Phase 4 contingent to the handiness of informations. We besides plan to better specification of our bing theoretical account if necessary.