Cultural Economics defines engagement by the different ways in which it takes topographic point: attending at unrecorded public presentations, ingestion of cultural goods through the media, and pattern of artistic activities. Using informations from the Survey of Public Participation in the Humanistic disciplines for the United States ( SPPA 2002 ) , this paper estimates attendance at different unrecorded humanistic disciplines and at museums. It builds upon parts on Cultural Economicss by Borgonovi ( 2004 ) and by Ateca Amestoy ( 2008 ) , every bit good as on Count Data arrested development theoretical accounts, largely applied antecedently to the demand for wellness services.The intent is to find through empirical observation if engagement in any of those activities corresponds to consecutive determination or whether the low attending rate is due to the heterogeneousness across subpopulations. . We estimate 7 engagement equations, one for attending to each activity: wind, classical music, opera, musicals, theater, concert dance and dance, and museums and art galleries. For each activity, we include as explanatory variables engagement through the media and through pattern. We find grounds supportive for the latent theoretical accounts and for the complement nature of the alternate ways of engagement to populate attending.
Introduction
There are a figure of grounds for an economic expert to analyze engagement in the humanistic disciplines. Economicss and single determination devising theoretical accounts could be challenged at some cases by issues refering the demand for cultural goods. For case, when seeking to explicate heterogeneousness in ascertained behaviour while keeping on gustatory sensation stableness hypotheses, one may detect that the more person has consumed in the yesteryear, the more he/she would wish to devour in the present. Rational add-on theory [ Stigler Becker1977 ] , for case, has tried to get the better of the perplexing fact of consumers deducing more and more public-service corporation out of the ingestion of cultural goods, without set uping exclusions to decreasing fringy public-service corporation. By patterning the personal cultural capital accretion procedure, Stigler and Becker were able to explicate positive habit-forming phenomena. However, there are besides matter-of-fact statements that call for a deep survey of the determiners of engagement in the humanistic disciplines, accounting for policy deductions. For some states, largely in the European Union, the equity in the entree to civilization ( loosely defined ) acquires the position of subjective right. This right becomes even constitutionally protected in several states, such as Spain. We have grounds that cultural engagement rate diverges a batch among different racial, societal, sex and economic groups. If worried about equity in entree, so we should be concerned non merely about placing which groups are less likely to take part, but besides about extricating and understanding which are the determiners of engagement itself.
Until really late, research on engagement in the humanistic disciplines had focused chiefly on who participates and who does non, without paying particular attending to the determiners of engagement [ McCarthy2001b ] and [ NEA2004 ] . Possibly, the chief part of Cultural Economics has been the debut of single determination devising theoretical accounts that enable to contrast through empirical observation the consequence of restraints and gustatory sensations over ascertained behaviour.
Economicss makes the differentiation between underlying penchants ( construction of the person ‘s public-service corporation map ) and revealed penchants ( chiefly through pick ) [ Frey2003 ] . This differentiation turns out to be peculiarly relevant when seeking to reason on the determiners of engagement in the humanistic disciplines through unrecorded attending. What we observe through the study that we will research is revealed penchant. Persons report how many times they attended to some cultural activities during the last twelvemonth. Typically, we like to deduce implicit in penchants from ascertained pick. However, we have to take into history that the single faces a forced maximization procedure of public-service corporation. Therefore, picks are non merely explained by the implicit in penchant construction, but chiefly, by differences in restraints. A individual may hold a high penchant for an artistic activity but may take non to take part given his/her deficiency of clip or given the fact that there are no installations nearby.
Engagement factors involve personal, family and institutional features that accommodate the personal resources that an agent has in order to fulfill a general demand called “ cultural grasp ” , every bit good as some step of personal gustatory sensations. In this paper, we will follow a Beckerian attack, and will see that gustatory sensations are stable. Particularly, we will concentrate on the relevancy of educational factors, of household conditions and of the consequence of engagement in that adherent under the two other alternate definitions of engagement: through the media and by actively executing. Could it be the instance that attending at unrecorded public presentations may be challenged by engagement through the media, a less clip intensive activity? We can understand that the intangible cultural good nowadays in each of these three definitions is the same. It is merely the stuff substrate which differs from one another, taking for different engineerings for the production of the “ cultural grasp ” trade good.
We take benefit of the rich dataset available for the survey of humanistic disciplines attending in the USA. The Survey of Public Participation in the Humanistic disciplines, in its 2002 release, provides us with a big dataset that contains elaborate information on engagement in the humanistic disciplines through the three types of engagement, specific humanistic disciplines instruction, and a package of socio economic factors sing the person and the family.
In this paper, we run an extension of the methodological analysis applied in a old paper [ Ateca Amestoy2008 ] , where we explored the most suited manner to gauge theatre attending in the United States. Here, we focus on the seven benchmark cultural activities, as defined by the USA National Endowment for the Humanistic disciplines. We estimate up to seven engagement equations, one for each of the undermentioned artistic activities: wind concerts, classical music concerts, opera, musicals, theatre, dance and concert dance and museums and art galleries. We do non account for any possible consequence of engagement in one subject on the other subjects. Therefore, possible complementarities across different subjects are non considered, and the involvement concentrates the consequence of different formats of engagement on attending.
We will besides seek to reply the undermentioned inquiry: are “ non departers ” truly “ ne’er departers ” ? “ Non departer ” being defined as a individual who reported in the study non engagement at a peculiar activity, and “ ne’er departer ” as a individual who would belong to a different subpopulation, potentially holding a nil gustatory sensation for those cultural activities. We design an empirical scheme that allows us to research heterogeneousness in behaviour. We besides account for the possibility of different determination devising procedures. Two households of theoretical accounts are estimated. First, latent theoretical accounts ( zero inflated count theoretical accounts ) and, so, consequences are confronted with those derived from a two portion theoretical account ( viz. , a hurdle theoretical account that combines a logit and a nothing truncated negative binomial theoretical account ) .
The program of the paper goes as follows. Section 2 overviews the literature on engagement in the humanistic disciplines, methods and findings. Section 3 briefly presents the informations and the empirical specification. Section 4 nowadayss the consequences, and subdivision 5 concludes.
Previous findings and appraisal attacks
Merely really late, did the literature focal point on the survey of the determiners of cultural engagement ( for a wide reappraisal, see [ Seaman2005 ] ) . Before, surveies described who did take part, alternatively of why he/she did [ Gray1995 ] , [ McCarthy2001b ] and [ NEA2004 ] . Contributions from Cultural Economics started proving the cogency of single determination theoretical accounts for cultural goods.
Closely related documents explain the influence of past ingestion capital on present demand, and the relevancy of general human capital and specific human cultural capital in finding the profile of people who participate more in the humanistic disciplines. Some of there going from theoretical theoretical accounts ( [ Ateca Amestoy2007 ] , [ Levy Garboua1996 ] and [ Stigler Becker1977 ] ) , and some others test through empirical observation the propositions derived from the former parts ( [ Borgonovi2004 ] , [ DiMaggio Mukhtar2004 ] , [ Fernandez Blanco2004 ] , [ Gray2003 ] , [ Upright2004 ] ) . Most of those empirical plants histories for phenomena such as rational dependence [ Stigler Becker1977 ] , or acquisition by devouring procedures [ Levy Garboua1996 ] .
The empirical scheme depends on the nature of the variables available. The most frequent attack has been the consideration of engagement as a dichotomous variable ( [ Gray2003 ] and [ Seaman2005 ] ) . Therefore, logistic or probit arrested developments where tally to pattern the chance of go toing at some peculiar manifestation of life humanistic disciplines.
If the manner in which variables have been elicited and recorded allows it, some other interesting inquiries can be addressed by utilizing different appraisal methods. For case, the one employed in an survey of the demand for film in Spain can pattern really heterogenous behaviour [ Fernandez Blanco2004 ] . These writers estimate a finite mixture theoretical account, so different behaviour for different subsamples can be estimated. If we believe that we can non separate between ne’er departers and attendants, but can separate between groups with high mean engagement ( “ partisans ” ) and with low mean engagement ( kick “ departers ” ) , so this sort of appraisal provides a good attack.
Borgonovi [ Borgonovi2004 ] uses the same dataset that we do, and dainties attending and frequence as two different entities. She justifies the appraisal of a binary theoretical account for engagement and an ordered theoretical account for frequence of engagement on the evidences of the undermentioned premise: there may be major differences qualifying the behaviour of occasional attendants and frequent participants in the unrecorded humanistic disciplines. For this writer, this is a call to analyze the 2 groups individually.
Count information theoretical accounts have been estimated before for theatre engagement utilizing this dataset. In a old article, we estimate engagement and compare the estimated consequences from an ordered probit, from a nothing inflated negative binomial and from a hurdle theoretical account [ Ateca Amestoy2008 ] . All those methods are loosely explained in that article. In this one, we proceed in precisely the same manner.
Data and empirical specification
The Survey of Public Participation in the Humanistic disciplines for the twelvemonth 2002 gathered information on engagement in the humanistic disciplines by US citizens between August 1st 2001 and August 1st 2002. It was the fifth survey in a series conducted by the Bureau of the Census for the National Endowment for the Humanistic disciplines since 1982. It was conducted as a addendum to the Current Population Survey [ BureauoftheCensus2003 ] . Households were sampled and, for each member over 18, the dataset contains information on attending at the undermentioned artistic activities: wind, classical music, opera, musicals, theater dramas, concert dance, dance, art museums, art trades, and visits to historical Parkss and memorials. It besides covers engagement by agencies of other types of cultural pattern such as the ingestion of cultural goods through the media, through recorded or printed affair, and through active pattern of artistic activities. Further, it provides information on instruction in humanistic disciplines, penchants for different types of cultural activities and school socialisation. The study collected 17,135 questionnaires for a representative sample of families in the USA. In each of the selected families, all persons over 18 were interviewed.
The descriptive statistics on cultural engagement for the USA ( see Table engagement related variables ) provides us with a first estimate to the heterogeneousness on engagement forms among persons. Let us take wind engagement in its three different types to depict the form. While there is a 89,2 % of people that did non go to any wind concert during the sampled twelvemonth ( standard mistake 0.003 ) , the mean figure of concerts among departers was 3,104 ( standard mistake 0.1390 ) . Given this heterogeneousness, due to the presence of a high proportion of non departers, mean attending is reduced to 0,331 times ( 0.1793 ) . Engagement through the media is captured by the proportion of people who listened to wind records ( 17,21 % with standard mistake of 0.003 ) , and by those who did it on the media ( 16,43 % , with 0.003 ) . Finally, 1,31 % performed wind themselves ( 0.001 ) . A similar form can be observed for each of the other 6 activities.
Overall, we can see that, even if some of these activities more popular than others ( 26,5 % of the grownup population visited some museum or art gallery in the old twelvemonth, whereas 8,7 % went to see concert dance or dance ) , there is a really large fraction of the population that did non go to to any of these activities. Actually, 59,56 % of the grownup population did non go to at any of the benchmark activities during the pervious twelvemonth. We would wish, hence, to put a suited empirical specification that is able to capture the possibility of unseen heterogeneousness in our population. Our dependent variable is, for every engagement equation, the figure of times that the person reported holding attended at that peculiar activity during the old twelvemonth. All of them are count variables that include a high proportion of nothing ( runing from 73,08 % of the observations for museums to up to 97,04 % of the observations for opera ) .
We will trust on both theoretical theoretical accounts of demand for cultural goods and on empirical regularities reported in the literature. Theoretical theoretical accounts going from beckerian theoretical accounts and see a basic trade good called “ cultural grasp ” that each person has to bring forth and devour in order to carry through that common, stable and basic demand. In order to bring forth cultural grasp, the agent has to apportion a figure of resources: chiefly income and clip. Typically, engagement by agencies of attending has ever been considered a clip intensive trade good with regard to engagement through the media. The former implies some travel cost and some old planning that can be avoided by the ingestion of that type of cultural goods in the media affair.
Income and clip get combined with other personal resources in order to bring forth enjoyable and meaningful experiences. One of the most of import variables in order to find how productive a individual might be uniting those resources is cultural capital. In our work, cultural capital is modeled as a personal resource that is accumulated by old ingestion and by formal and informal instruction. Given the societal dimension of engagement in the unrecorded humanistic disciplines, we will besides see some household related variables. Unfortunately, from our sample, we can non place joint engagement for persons in the same families. However, we can prove simple hypotheses of the consequence of the engagement of other member of the household over owns attending, in the spirit of the work by Upwright [ Upright2004 ] .
We must nevertheless account for some of the restraints over the resources of the person. Income will be the first one, but besides some variables that determine clip handiness. Since we do non happen in the study a direct step of the sum of free clip, we try to suit clip handiness by presenting labour position and family composing related variables. A variable that informs about the penchant for that activity is included.
We will besides command for several personal variables that influence cultural engagement. Those are what Seaman calls “ assorted factors ” , such as sex, age and ethnicity [ Seaman2005 ] . Given that there is wide grounds of attending being a largely urban phenomenon, we include the size of the home ground. Explanations for this regularity take into history that unrecorded humanistic disciplines are largely provided in urban countries. Therefore, attending is populating in non urban countries is capable to higher implicit costs ( if merely, because of travel costs and the sum of clip required to make the locale ) . Given the importance of location and supply handiness, we control for abode by seting some construction in the discrepancy covariance matrix. In our appraisals, we will let for constellating among observations that belong to the same amalgamate metropolitan statistical countries ( CMSA ) , as defined by the Bureau of the Census.
This set of explanatory variables, would find the sum of resources allocated and the engineering being used. But, as mentioned before, engagement by agencies of attending is non the lone manner in which a peculiar class of cultural goods can be consumed. To prove the influence of engagement through the media and through active pattern, we introduce for each of the engagement equations, the reported engagement by those two alternate agencies.
Participation equation for a peculiar activity is determined by the undermentioned explanatory variables:
• demographic variables: age ( we introduce silent persons for up to 8 age intervals, specifying people on their mid-fortiess as the baseline ) , sex ( female is the base ) , ethnicity ( black, Indian and island-dweller ; white is the baseline ) , and labour position ( silent persons for employed full clip baseline, employed portion clip, unemployed, retired, non in the labour force ) .
• household variables: income ( 4 quartiles, the baseline is the first 1 ) , family size ( as a count variable ) , and familiar engagement ( a silent person that accounts for the fact that person else in the family reported holding attended to that subject ) .
• geographic variables: size of home ground ( metropolitan baseline, cardinal, balance ) .
• cultural capital variables: ain degree of formal instruction ( 5 degrees ) , parental instruction ( both parents ‘ , the same silent persons ) and specific instruction in the humanistic disciplines commanding for get downing age ( the baseline is no specific instruction, one of the silent persons controls for holding started before 18, and another if started after 18 ) .
• penchants: would travel more if no limitations ( a silent person variable ) .
• alternate engagement: by agencies of media and by pattern ( by records, by books, by media and executing or moving ) .
In what follows, we will concentrate on finding the most suited appraisal method to acquire some estimations that allow us to better understand the determiners of engagement. Therefore, when seeking to pattern attending at unrecorded humanistic disciplines, we will let separating between what determines that a individual is more/less likely to go to at executing humanistic disciplines, and what determines that a individual is more/less likely to go to more, or with higher strength. When making so, we will be able to prove through empirical observation if there is some grounds back uping that some of these types of engagement correspond to consecutive determination, or if the distinguishable behaviour is due to the heterogeneousness of different subpopulations.
The appraisal process goes as follows. We estimate up to 4 count informations arrested development theoretical accounts: Poisson, Negative Binomial ( II ) ; Zero Inflated Poisson, Zero Inflated Negative Binomial ( II ) . We do the hypotheses proving suited to find the best among them. As we will discourse below, for all our appraisals it turns out that best tantrum is provided by Zero Inflated Negative Binomial ( II ) theoretical accounts. Particularly, a logit regulations the rising prices portion of the theoretical account, i.e. , the chance of belonging to one subpopulation or another ; and a Negative Binomial II distribution regulations the counts of the theoretical account, including zero, each of which comes with a positive chance conditioned on the fact of belonging to one precise subpopulation. That last theoretical account belongs to the household of latent category theoretical accounts. We find grounds of underlying heterogeneousness in the ascertained behaviour. Actually, we find that observed behaviour is the commixture of two distinguishable subpopulations: the “ ne’er departers ” and the “ departers ” . The type of the person is non elicited in the study, but inferred from behaviour. Never departers find their optimum in nothing. Among the departers, we take into history non merely the positive values of the dependant variable, but besides some of the nothing that consequence from corner solutions. Should some of the limitations be relaxed, the person would go to a positive sum of times.
We compare the consequences derived from the selected theoretical account with those consequences derived from the appraisal of a hurdle theoretical account. We estimate a two portion theoretical account formed by a logit for the rising prices portion and a nothing truncated negative binomial for the positive counts. The behavioural theoretical accounts underlying hurdle theoretical accounts determine that determination doing procedure consists on two parts. First, any individual is a non departer until there is some alteration that determines that the single starts traveling. All the nothings come from the same distribution, and some variables make the single cross the hurdle and go a departer. Once that determination is taken, the nothing truncated procedure regulations the positive counts. By utilizing the goodness of tantrum and the Bayesian information standards, we compare how good each of the theoretical accounts performs. As we will discourse below, we find grounds in our appraisals that support that there are no two portion processes for humanistic disciplines attending. For every activity, we find that latent category theoretical accounts are the 1s supplying a best tantrum.
Consequences
We start by discoursing the selected appraisal process, since we find grounds supportive for the latent category theoretical account with regard to the two parts theoretical account. Therefore, we gain some penetrations on the nature of the engagement determination doing procedure. We do non happen grounds that indicates that engagement is a two portion determination theoretical account, in the sense that a individual foremost decides whether to be an attender or non and, latter, decides how many times he/she wants to go to. What we find, for all the considered activities, is that heterogeneousness in ascertained behaviour is determined by the implicit in heterogeneousness. There are two subpopulations: a first one of ne’er departers, characterized by some peculiar traits, some of which are common to any type of activity ; there is a 2nd subpopulation formed by those who may go to a positive figure of times. Therefore, we find that all zero results of our dependant variable do non come from the same distribution.
Recall that by utilizing the Zero Inflated Negative Binomial to gauge the engagement equations, we have found grounds of the underlying being of two different sub populations. Therefore, we have estimated for each of those engagement equations a portion of the theoretical account that regulations the chance of being a ne’er departer, i.e. , the rising prices portion ; and another portion that regulations the strength of engagement, i.e. , the chance of each of the counts. For the rising prices portion of the theoretical account, a positive mark on the estimated coefficient informs that the variable has a positive consequence over the chance of being a ne’er departer. For the count portion of it, a positive coefficient determines the higher chance of go toing more times. Discussion of the appraisal consequences starts by showing the consequence of each of the packages of explanatory variables and associating our empirical findings with the anticipation of traditional theoretical accounts and with old consequences.
Sing the age variable, even if it is statistically important, the consequence is non really large. We find monotonic and positive effects for the count portion of the theoretical account of classical music concerts. The same for the count portion of the concert dance and dance attending. However, there is a somehow U opposite form for museum attending.
One of the regularities recurrently reported in the literature on engagement determines the high feminisation of engagement in the humanistic disciplines. By agencies of our analysis, we have been able to separate that gender has merely influence for the rising prices portion of the theoretical account. For about every activity, with the exclusion of wind and musicals, work forces have higher chance of being ne’er departers. However, when measuring the impact of the sex variable over frequence of engagement, we merely find statistically important effects for theatre ( a negative impact over the count ) , and for dance ( a positive 1 ) .
Another type of consequences that come out of engagement surveies is that participants are wealthier than non participants. We find out that income has so an of import function in the rising prices portion of the theoretical account. There is a about monotone consequence of income in the rising prices portion ( in the sense that higher income reduces the chance of ne’er go toing ) . No statistically important effects are found for opera and musicals. Surprisingly, we besides found negative consequence in the count portion for classical music concerts and for museums.
Sing the labour position and family composing variables, which accommodate the influence of some variables over clip handiness, we do non happen a clear form for labour market related variables. However, if of a little magnitude, family size has a negative impact. Overall, if matrimonial position has statistically important consequence, it has a positive 1 with regard to the baseline ( being married ) . Familiar engagement has a really large impact in the rising prices portion of the theoretical account, cut downing dramatically the chance of ne’er traveling. In some instances, we find grounds for its consequence over strength ( greatest for opera, smaller for classical music concerts ) .
With regard to the size of the home ground, in our appraisals we find scarce grounds supportive for the urban character of engagement in the humanistic disciplines. Not populating in a metropolitan country, but populating in a cardinal one reduces the chance of of all time traveling for opera, concert dance and museums. No consequence is found for any of the count parts of the engagement equations.
Overall, the effects of a greatest magnitude come from owns formal and informal instruction. We find that if parental instruction has any consequence, it is by agencies of male parents ‘ instruction and largely in the rising prices portion ( so we conjecture that it could be capturing more of a wealth consequence, and less of an early exposure or transmittal consequence ) . Sing ain formal instruction, our findings describe the undermentioned forms: Monotone consequence for wind in both parts, even more marked for theatre and for museums ; largely effects over the rising prices portion for opera, musicals and dance ; for classical music, the consequence over the rising prices is monotone, but U shaped over the count portion. We find out that the magnitude of the coefficients for ain formal instruction variables is, on norm, twice every bit large as the 1s for income, hence back uping the once stated fact that educational variables have greater explanatory power than income variables. For humanistic disciplines specific humanistic disciplines preparation, we find a large consequence on rising prices for music related activities ( wind, authoritative, opera, musicals ) . Besides strength is determined by those variables for museums and classical music. Remember that we distinguish developing by the fact that it started when grownup or before. We find that if both are important, there is a bigger consequence if started when grownup.
One of the involvements of this paper is to find the relationship between the options to populate engagement ( i.e. to attending ) : viz. , engagement through the media and through humanistic disciplines pattern. For other affair of engagement, we find out that it enhances engagement for every adherent ( when comparable, there is a higher consequence of records or books with regard to some inactive media use ) . It besides increases strength for every subject. When sing moving or executing, there is no common grounds: for wind, it determines higher strength ; for classical music, both ; playing has merely consequence over the rising prices. If statistically important, it ever has a positive mark for chance of departer every bit good as for strength, as expected. We can note the large magnitude of the estimated coefficients. However, this latter is the most infrequent type of engagement.
Finally, the consequence of the spell more variable is really large in the rising prices portion ( and for all engagement ) . It extremely reduces chance of being “ ne’er departer ” , and determines strength for theatre, concert dance and museums.
Decisions and concluding treatment
In this paper, we have provided grounds that, for these informations, all the bring forthing procedures seem to be a finite mixture. We can, hence, explain the heterogeneousness in the ascertained behaviour by sing that there is a latent procedure by which a individual can be of either one of these types: ne’er departer or departer. However, some of the consumers in the departer group can make up one’s mind non to go to, given the forced maximization procedure, so non all nothings come from the same distribution. We have besides found grounds that engagement determination is non a two portion determination.
Once that we have selected the suited appraisal technique, we have characterized the binary rising prices procedure and the count one. For the binary rising prices, we have estimated the unseen latent procedure. For the count portion of the theoretical account we have estimated the chance of a go toing a zero or positive figure of times conditioned on the fact of non being a ne’er departer. By making so, we have been able to extricate the consequence of a package of explanatory variables over the two distinguishable procedures.
One of the chief consequences of our paper has been the complementary character of the three ways of cultural engagement. Participation through the media and other affairs determines both higher strength of engagement and smaller chance of being a ne’er departer. For active engagement, it determines higher strength and, for some instances, besides smaller chance of ne’er traveling.
Our consequences may cast some visible radiation over the ever controversial enterprises such as the broadcast medium of the Berlin Philharmonic Digital Concert Hall, frequently considered menaces over unrecorded humanistic disciplines. Even if we neglect the societal facets of engagement by attending, there might be still the sense of singularity and, in footings of the piano player Daniel Baremboin, “ one timeness ” of attending [ Battle, 2009 ] .
Recognitions
I would wish to admit the cordial reception of Prof. John O`Hagan and of the Institute for International Integration Studies in Trinity College Dublin, where portion of this research was conducted. Previous work was presented in the ACEI Conference in Boston, June 2008. Fiscal support from the Ministry of Research, Spain ( SJE 2006/10827 ) and from the Basque Government ( IT.241 07 ) is acknowledged.
Mentions
Ateca Amestoy, V. ( 2007 ) , Cultural Capital and Demand. Economics Bulletin, Vol. 26 no. 1 pp. 1 9.
Ateca Amestoy, V. ( 2008 ) , Determining Heterogeneous Behavior for Theater Attendance. Journal of Cultural Economics, Vol. 32 ( 2 ) : 127 151.
Becker, G.S. ( 1965 ) , A Theory of the Allocation of Time. Economic Journal, 75 ( September ) : 493 517.
Borgonovi, F. ( 2004 ) , Performing Humanistic disciplines: an economic approach.Applied Economicss 36: 1871 1885, 2004.
Bureau of the Census ( 2003 ) , Current Population Survey, August 2002: Public Participation in the Arts Supplement. Technical Documentation Attachments.Realized by the Bureau of the Census for the National Endowment for the Arts, Washington.
Cameron, Colin A. and P.K. Trivedi ( 1998 ) , Regression Analysis of Count Data. Cambridge University Press.
Deb, P. and P.K. Trivedi ( 2002 ) , The construction of demand for wellness attention latent category versus two portion theoretical accounts. Journal of Health Economics 21 ( 4 ) : 601 625.
DiMaggio, P. ( 2004 ) Gender, Networks, and Cultural Capital. Poeticss 32: 99 103.
DiMaggio, P. and T. Mukhtar ( 2004 ) . Humanistic disciplines Participation as Cultural Capital in the United States, 1982 2002: Signs of Decline? Poeticss 32: 169 194.
DiMaggio, P.J. and F. Ostrower ( 1990 ) . Engagement in the humanistic disciplines by Black and White Americans. In Pankratz, D. , & A ; Morrie. V. ( explosive detection systems ) The Future of the Humanistic disciplines: Public Policy and Humanistic disciplines Research: pp. 105 140. Praeger Press.
Fernandez Blanco, V. , Prieto Rodriguez, J. and Orea Sanchez, L. ( 2004 ) . Movie enthusiasts versus cinemagoers in Spain: A Latent Class Model Approach. Presented at 13th ACEI Conference, University of Illinois at Chicago.
Frey, B.S. ( 2003 ) . Arts & A ; Economicss: Analysis & A ; Cultural Policy. Springer Verlag, New York.
Gapinski, James H. ( 1986 ) . The Lively Arts as Substitutes for the Lively Arts. American Economic Review 76 ( 2 ) : 20 25.
Gray, Charles M. ( 1995 ) . Turning On and Tuning In: Media Participation in the Arts. National Endowment for the Arts Research Division Report # 33, Seven Locks Press.
Gray, Charles M. ( 2003 ) . Engagement. In Towse, R. ( erectile dysfunction ) . Edward Elgar.
Hilbe, J.M. ( 2007 ) . Negative Binomial Regression. Cambridge University Press, New York.
Levy Garboua, L. and C. Montmarquette ( 1996 ) . A Microeconometric Study of Theater Demand. Journal of Cultural Economics 20: 25 50.
Long, J.S. and J.Freese ( 2006 ) . Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata ( 2nd edition ) . Stata Press.
McCarthy, K.F. , Ondaatje, E.H. , and L. Zakaras ( 2001 ) . Guide to the Literature on engagement in the Arts. RAND Corporation.
Mullahy, J. ( 1998 ) . Much bustle about two: reconsidering retransformations and the two portion theoretical account in wellness econometrics.Journal of Health Economics 17: 247 281.
Mullahy, J. ( 1986 ) . Specification and testing of some modified count informations theoretical accounts. Journal of Econometrics 33: 341 365.
National Endowment for the Arts ( 2003 ) . Survey of Public Participation in the Humanistic disciplines 2002. National Endowment for the Humanistic disciplines.
National Endowment for the Arts ( 2004 ) . 2002 Survey of Public Participation in the Arts. Research Division Report # 45. National Endowment for the Humanistic disciplines.
Seaman, B.A. ( 2005 ) . Attendance and Public Participation in the Performing Humanistic disciplines: A Review of the Empirical Literature. Nonprofit Studies Program W.P 05 03, Georgia State University.
Stigler, G. and G. S. Becker ( 1977 ) . De Gustibus Non est Disputandum. Journal of Political Economy 67 ( 1 ) : 76 90.
Upright, C.B. ( 2004 ) . Social capital and bridal engagement: spousal influences on attending at humanistic disciplines event
